A Simple Favor 2 – Release Date, Cast, Plot and Reviews

The highly anticipated sequel to the 2018 thriller-comedy has arrived. “Another Simple Favor,” directed by Paul Feig, brings back the dynamic duo of Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively in a story that jumps forward five years to explore murder, betrayal, and an extravagant Italian wedding. The film premiered at South by Southwest in March 2025 before making its streaming debut, marking a notable shift from theatrical distribution for the franchise.

The original “A Simple Favor” captivated audiences with its dark humor and unpredictable plot twists, grossing nearly $100 million worldwide against a modest budget. The sequel promised to continue that formula, setting the stage on the sun-drenched island of Capri with an entirely new mystery to unravel. Fans of the first film will recognize the chemistry between the lead actresses while discovering how their characters’ lives have evolved since the events of 2018.

What is Another Simple Favor 2?

Another Simple Favor is a 2025 black comedy mystery film and the direct sequel to the 2018 hit “A Simple Favor.” The project was developed by Lionsgate in partnership with Amazon MGM Studios, representing a significant evolution in distribution strategy for the franchise. While the first film received a theatrical release, the sequel debuted exclusively on Amazon Prime Video, reflecting broader industry shifts toward streaming platforms for mid-budget genre films.

• Sequel to the 2018 original that earned nearly $100 million worldwide
• Filmed on location in Italy, including UNESCO World Heritage Site Villa Adriana
• Premiered at South by Southwest on March 7, 2025
• Released exclusively on Amazon Prime Video on May 1, 2025
• Incorporates black comedy, mystery, and thriller elements
• Story jumps forward five years from the events of the first film

When is the Release Date for Another Simple Favor 2?

Development and Announcement Timeline

The journey toward “Another Simple Favor” began shortly after the original film’s commercial success. Lionsgate and Amazon MGM Studios announced the development in May 2022, signaling confidence in the franchise’s potential. However, production did not commence immediately, as negotiations with the principal cast and creative team took time to finalize. The project remained in various stages of development through 2022 and into 2023.

Principal photography ultimately began in late March 2024 and concluded on May 26, 2024. The decision to release the film directly on streaming was announced during the production phase in 2024, a strategic choice that positioned the film for a different audience model than its predecessor. The world premiere took place at South by Southwest on March 7, 2025, with the film becoming available to stream on Amazon Prime Video exactly eight weeks later on May 1, 2025.

1. May 2022 – Development announced by Lionsgate and Amazon MGM Studios
2. Late March 2024 – Principal photography begins
3. May 26, 2024 – Filming wraps
4. March 7, 2025 – World premiere at South by Southwest
5. May 1, 2025 – Release on Amazon Prime Video

Who is in the Cast and Crew of Another Simple Favor 2?

Returning Principal Cast

The sequel reunites the core ensemble from the 2018 original, ensuring continuity in the performances that audiences fell in love with five years earlier. Anna Kendrick returns as Stephanie Smothers, the widowed vlogger and amateur detective whose life took an unexpected turn after befriending the enigmatic Emily Nelson. Blake Lively portrays Emily Nelson once again, bringing her signature style and complex characterization to the role that launched significant post-film attention.

Supporting cast members Henry Golding, Andrew Rannells, and Bashir Salahuddin reprise their respective roles as Sean Townsend, Darren, and Detective Ben Summerville. This continuity extends the narrative threads from the first film, particularly those involving the ongoing investigation into the mysteries surrounding Emily’s past.

New Cast Additions

Michele Morrone joins the franchise as Dante Versano, Emily’s wealthy Italian fiancé whose family has connections to organized crime. Morrone brings international star power to the project, having built a significant following through European productions. Allison Janney appears in a new role, while Elena Sofia Ricci and Alex Newell round out the ensemble of new characters populating the sequel’s Italian setting.

Elizabeth Perkins replaces Jean Smart in the role of Margaret McLanden, Emily’s mother, representing a notable change in the supporting cast from the original film. This recasting brings fresh dynamics to the family relationships that factor prominently into the sequel’s plot.

Behind the Camera

Paul Feig returns to the director’s chair for the sequel, maintaining creative continuity with the original. His vision for the franchise balances the dark comedy elements with genuine mystery, a combination that proved successful with audiences in 2018. The production team filmed extensively on location in Italy, utilizing the scenic backdrop of Capri and the historical grandeur of Villa Adriana, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, to establish the film’s distinct visual identity.

What is the Plot of Another Simple Favor 2?

Another Simple Favor picks up five years after the events of the first film. Stephanie Smothers, portrayed by Anna Kendrick, has transformed her harrowing experience into professional success, becoming a famous true crime vlogger and amateur detective. Her memoir detailing her friendship with Emily Nelson and the subsequent imprisonment that followed has made her a recognizable figure in the true crime community.

The narrative takes a dramatic turn when Emily Nelson appears at one of Stephanie’s book signings. Emily, currently filing an appeal of her imprisonment, arrives with an unexpected request: she wants Stephanie to serve as her maid of honor for her wedding to Dante Versano. Dante, played by Michele Morrone, is a wealthy Italian businessman whose family has apparent connections to organized crime.

Emily applies characteristic pressure to secure Stephanie’s agreement, dangling promises of increased book sales while hinting at potential legal action. This manipulation sets the stage for the film’s central conflict, drawing Stephanie back into Emily’s orbit despite the danger such involvement historically carried.

Setting and Central Conflict

The wedding ceremony takes place on the island of Capri, Italy, providing a glamorous and tension-filled backdrop for the unfolding events. The choice of location is far from incidental, as the film leverages the contrast between the scenic Mediterranean setting and the darker elements of murder, betrayal, and deception that define the franchise.

The story delivers the twists and turns audiences expect from the series, with multiple revelations that reshape understanding of the characters’ motivations and relationships. As with the original film, the sequel uses its genre elements to explore themes of friendship, loyalty, and the complexity of interpersonal relationships when trust has been fundamentally compromised.

Critical Reception and Reviews

Another Simple Favor received mixed reviews from critics upon release, with particular criticism directed at the screenplay’s failure to deliver a compelling narrative despite strong performances and visually striking production design. The Rotten Tomatoes consensus describes the film as “a dazzling disappointment—a sequel that banks on Blake Lively’s star power and a parade of jaw-dropping outfits but forgets to bring a compelling story.”

Jacob Oller of The A.V. Club awarded the film a C+ grade, acknowledging that the chemistry between Kendrick and Lively remains engaging and that the film’s characteristic plot twists persist throughout. However, Oller noted that “the heat powering the concept has cooled to the extent that, despite the increased body count, the sequel feels as perfunctory as its title.”

Accolades and Industry Recognition

Despite mixed critical reception, Another Simple Favor earned notable industry recognition. Paul Feig received a nomination for the SXSW Headliner Audience Award at the March 2025 ceremony, acknowledging the film’s premiere success at the festival. Additionally, the film was nominated for Best Television Movie at the Astra TV Awards on June 10, 2025, a category that reflects the streaming platform distribution model.

These nominations suggest that while critical opinion was divided, the film achieved sufficient industry standing to warrant consideration for major awards. The recognition at streaming-focused award ceremonies also aligns with the film’s distribution strategy and target audience engagement.

Filming Locations and Production Details

Principal photography for Another Simple Favor took place over approximately two months, beginning in late March 2024 and concluding on May 26, 2024. The production team chose Italy as the primary shooting location, selecting sites that would provide the glamorous Mediterranean backdrop essential to the sequel’s wedding-centric narrative.

Capri, the famous island in the Bay of Naples, serves as the primary setting for the film’s wedding sequence. The location’s inherent beauty and luxury associations contributed to the visual spectacle that critics acknowledged, even when questioning other aspects of the production.

Equally significant is the filming at Villa Adriana, also known as Hadrian’s Villa, a UNESCO World Heritage Site located near Rome. This ancient Roman imperial palace complex provided unique historical context and architectural grandeur that elevated the production’s visual ambition, demonstrating the sequel’s increased scope compared to its predecessor.

Streaming Availability and Distribution

Another Simple Favor released exclusively on Amazon Prime Video on May 1, 2025, representing a strategic decision by Lionsgate and Amazon MGM Studios regarding the film’s distribution model. This approach differs substantially from the original film’s theatrical release, acknowledging the changed landscape of film consumption and the strategic value of franchise content to streaming platforms.

The streaming release makes the film accessible to Amazon Prime subscribers without additional payment, positioning it as a key title in the platform’s content library. This strategy reflects broader industry patterns where streaming services acquire or produce sequel content specifically to drive subscriber retention and acquisition.

Summary

Another Simple Favor delivers a continuation of the dark comedy mystery franchise that began in 2018, reuniting Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively under Paul Feig’s direction. The film premiered at South by Southwest in March 2025 before streaming on Amazon Prime Video, introducing new cast members including Michele Morrone as Emily’s mafia-connected fiancé. While the production’s Italian locations and visual presentation received recognition, critical response proved mixed, with reviewers noting that spectacular presentation could not fully compensate for narrative shortcomings. The film earned nominations for the SXSW Headliner Audience Award and the Astra TV Award for Best Television Movie, demonstrating industry acknowledgment of its achievements despite divided critical opinion. For related content, see our coverage of Slow Horses Season 6.

Sources and References

The critics’ consensus on Rotten Tomatoes describes it as “a dazzling disappointment—a sequel that banks on Blake Lively’s star power and a parade of jaw-dropping outfits but forgets to bring a compelling story.”

Rotten Tomatoes

“The heat powering the concept has cooled to the extent that, despite the increased body count, the sequel feels as perfunctory as its title.”

The A.V. Club

Frequently Asked Questions